I have recently had a string of bad luck and it has me wondering about the reviews that appear in Cigar Aficionado. Specifically, I have been trying cigars that were reviewed in the magazine (buying four versus one to ensure a sampling) and have not been impressed with the results. From plugged and hard to draw to flavor that is less than other labels that I have come to trust I have not been impressed with what the magazine is rating so highly.
The thought begins………..do the companies pay to get reviewed? The possibility is daunting in that if a label can flourish based on paid reviews and not on quality then I am buying bad advice. We want to trust the “published expert” but what is the reality of the review? I paid a pretty good price to try these rated cigars and came away with doubt.
For now I am sticking with the labels that have been good to me in the past and it will probably be awhile before I trust the review of a major cigar publication.